Can Nicholas Robertson Prove To Toronto's Full Forward Squad? – Hockey Writers – Toronto Maple Leafs

Nicholas Robertson is in a critical situation with the Toronto Maple Leafs. Once considered a top prospect with the potential to become a dynamic player, his path has been hampered by injuries and inconsistency. In the 2024-25 season, he faces the challenge of proving himself again—not just as a roster spot, but for his future with the team. After two preseason games, where does Robertson stand?

Two Preseason Games: Two Different Positions

One of the biggest surprises during the Maple Leafs' preseason was Robertson's move from left wing to right wing. This came after he missed the first preseason game, and was reinserted into the right tackle role during the second contest against the Ottawa Senators.

Related: Latest Pitch To Dump Marner On Leafs UFA Exchange Not Crazy

Why the change? It would be a smart decision, indicating that the Maple Leafs may have other plans for their left side. There are speculations that Max Pacioretty, if signed by the Maple Leafs, may take the role of the top six on the left wing. That will take Robertson out of his natural position, forcing him to adapt to a new environment if he wants to stay on the roster. Was the shift to the right side part of the test to evaluate Robertson's work flexibility? Although he is known for his deadly shooting and offensive instincts, the question is whether he can adapt to a different side of the ice, especially at the NHL level.

In his first preseason game at right wing, Robertson logged 18:40 of ice time, one of the highest totals on the team. That usage rate suggests the coaching staff will give him every opportunity to prove he can handle the new position. While it's still early in the season, Robertson's adaptability will be crucial to finding a place on the Maple Leafs' crowded forward line.

In last night's second preseason game, Robertson logged 16:35 of ice time, this time on the left wing. Bringing him back to his old position could mean the coaching staff sees him joining the Maple Leafs roster. Or, at the very least, the coaching staff wants to see him in both positions. That, in itself, is not a bad thing.

Two of Robertson's Greatest Moments: One Big, One Not So Big

However, the game had two standout moments that highlighted Robertson's ongoing conditioning process. One was good, but the other was not so good. In a great highlight reel for Robertson, he chased down a Canadiens defenseman as he came out of his defense, stole the puck, and quickly turned to score. As he moved quickly, he shot past the goalkeeper and scored the winning goal. This game showed exactly what the Maple Leafs coaching staff has been looking for in Robertson—a dynamic offensive player who is tireless defensively and never stops playing—a key moment that highlighted his ability to make an impact.

Related: Battle of the Maple Leafs' Bottom-Six Roster: Who's In, Who's Out?

In a not-so-good moment, a lapse in Robertson's thinking may have hurt teammate William Nylander. At that point, Robertson tried to give Nylander more pressure by pressing down on the stick. The pressure caused Nylander to lose his balance and collide with a Montreal player while skating. Nylander left the game and did not return.

When asked about the incident after the game, Robertson noted that it just happened. He didn't think much of it. Head coach Craig Berube also made little of it (at least publicly). On the sidelines, he may need to help Robertson fine-tune his decisions, especially in high-pressure moments. The incident underscored the learning curve Robertson is facing as he works to find his place in the lineup.

Despite not going well with Nylander, Robertson showed his speed, effort, and offensive instincts during his time on the ice. Adaptability will be key, as the Maple Leafs are still searching for the right mix in their front six. If he can show versatility and reliability, he may gain more exposure in various situations.

Robertson Must Stay Healthy And Play More

One of the resulting questions surrounding Robertson has always been his ability to stay healthy. After a series of injuries derailed his previous seasons, including a serious shoulder injury last year, Robertson's fitness is under scrutiny. Standing at 5-foot-9 and 165 pounds, he must prove he can handle the physical demands of an NHL season.

Related: Maple Leafs Position Battles to Keep an Eye on

In addition to staying healthy, Robertson must show consistency in his game. His brief stint in the NHL showed flashes of offensive potential, but he also went through a period of ineffectiveness. His reliability as a defensive player also needs some work. He has the engine, but he doesn't always make the right calls defensively. This preseason is important for him to show that he can deliver every night, regardless of his role or ice time.

The Stakes Are High for Robertson

Robertson's performance in the preseason will likely determine his fate in the season. He is fighting for a place in a competitive forward team, and there are no guarantees. With talented young players like Matthew Knies and veterans like Calle Järnkrok and David Kämpf in the mix, Robertson must excel in all aspects of his game—not just as a scorer but as a player responsible for both.

This preseason comes with trade rumors running rampant. Robertson's name has been floated as a potential asset in offseason trade packages. If he doesn't take advantage of this opportunity, the Maple Leafs may look to move him (even if for little return) for a quick upgrade elsewhere, possibly with protection. That said, trading Robertson risks losing a young player with significant upside if he can ultimately stay healthy and put it all together.

Where is Robertson Fit?

If Robertson can stay with the Maple Leafs, the next question is where he fits on the roster. Given the depth and competition on the wings, his best opportunity may come as a third-line option, providing an attacking punch to the bottom six. However, he will need to surpass his competition, proving that he can contribute beyond scoring goals, especially in defensive play and forechecking.

Robertson's versatility, including the ability to play both wings, could work for him. It gives the coaching staff more options to put him on different lines depending on the needs of the team. But Robertson's clock is ticking, and every preseason game counts as the team finalizes its opening night roster.

Related: Toronto Maple Leafs: Was It Time To Trade Nazem Kadri?

At halftime of last night's game, Sportsnet's Nick Kypreos and Justin Bourne panel were clear in their belief that if Robertson doesn't make the Maple Leafs' roster after training camp, there is no chance he will go through waivers. After scoring 14 goals last season, another team would likely snap him up immediately. Maybe that's exactly what he was hoping for. This preseason feels like a make-or-break time for Robertson. He finds a spot on the Maple Leafs roster or finds himself on the road with a new team.

Highlights: Important Preseason for Robertson

Robertson's future with the Maple Leafs hangs in the balance. After two preseason games, he showed his potential but also made some costly mistakes. Upcoming games will determine whether he can find a spot on Toronto's roster or whether his journey will continue with another NHL team via trade or losing him through waivers.

This preseason isn't just another interview for Robertson — it could be a turning point in his career. With health, consistency, and smart play, he can finally stake his claim as a regular NHL contributor. If not, the Maple Leafs may decide his time in Toronto is over.